About JW Watch (formerly JW Survey)

message3

It is my pleasure to give you a warm welcome to JWWatch.org. This website has been launched to give voice to millions of Jehovah’s Witnesses around the world who would not normally have the opportunity to say what they really think about the Watch Tower Society, or the teachings and practices of the Governing Body.

The Governing Body has yet to express any interest in hearing the views of ordinary witnesses. Their mantra is: “We talk, you listen!”

If you are a Jehovah’s Witness, or a former Witness, you will be aware that the opinions of rank and file publishers (and even elders) are rarely sought by the Society. The small number of men making up the Governing Body have declared themselves the “faithful and discreet slave” of Matthew 24:45, thus claiming sole control over the organization’s teachings and policies. These men are most certainly NOT interested in the opinions of the “silent majority” of Witnesses under their authority. If they are, they have a strange way of showing it!

This website historically sought to redress that balance by means of an annual survey that was conducted anonymously throughout the world. The first survey was taken in 2011, and immediately attracted the opinions of 1,118 voters before closing at the end of the year. The results were posted to the Governing Body for their attention and review but, predictably, they never replied.

The following year, 2012, the survey received votes from 1,488 current and former Witnesses, most of whom expressed their concern at various Watchtower teachings. The remarkable events of that year (the Candace Conti case and the “new light” about the faithful slave) certainly seemed to get people talking.

Subsequent surveys have allowed in excess of 6,000 per year to express their true feelings about the organization and its leadership, and we are optimistic this number will only increase as JWsurvey grows in popularity.

As we move into 2021, JW Survey has become JW Watch. The John Cedars YouTube Channel has become the Lloyd Evans Channel.

These changes represent where we are as a unified team, dedicated to accurate, non-sensational news about the activities of Jehovah’s Witnesses and their leadership. You will see content that represents investigative reporting, documentary, and occasionally opinions about the state of affairs of more than 8 million members of the Witness faith.

A website for all

This website has been created and made available as a free resource so that anyone, whether they are a former or current Witness, or in some way associated with Witness friends or relatives, can give their honest opinions about Watchtower and the increasingly cult-like direction in which it is headed.

We adopt a strictly non-religious viewpoint, meaning we refuse to promote any belief structure in particular. For this reason, we cannot be accused of trying to “draw off followers.” We are merely interested in garnering the views of ordinary Witnesses and reporting on the facts.

The Governing Body of Jehovah’s Witnesses has not authorized or sponsored the survey, and it is run entirely without any influence or input from them. However, we genuinely feel that the brothers who serve on the Governing Body, having assumed such overwhelming responsibility, should take note of how ordinary Witnesses and the general public feel about their leadership, since millions of lives are affected by decisions they make at their private weekly meetings.

Who started this website?

My name is Lloyd Evans, and I am the founder of this website. I set it up in October 2011 with the help of a fellow activist while I was still one of Jehovah’s Witnesses, writing under the pseudonym “John Cedars.” Eventually, I left the organization for conscientious reasons. You can read my story on this link.

I first had the idea to begin gathering the opinions of Jehovah’s Witnesses and their associates around the world because of a variety of issues that continue to be of real concern to me. I believe that ordinary Witnesses who devote their entire lives to loyally serving Jehovah, through what purports to be God’s spirit-directed organization, should have some say in the decisions that are made on their behalf.

It is my belief that not all is well within the organization. I don’t consider many of the teachings and practices encouraged by the Governing Body to have been formulated with the best interests of ordinary Witnesses at heart.

An unmerciful practice

For example, take the practice of shunning or “disfellowshipping.” The Apostle Paul’s words to the Corinthian congregation were as follows:

Screen Shot 2016-06-29 at 13.36.52

Paul’s words in 1 Corinthians about the disfellowshipping arrangement never called for family members to be torn apart

Clearly the Apostle Paul was delivering this admonition for the purpose of keeping the congregation clean. But to what extent should these words be applied? By saying “not even eating with such a man,” Paul indicated that his words weren’t directed against family members (who would daily eat with one another), but against other brothers in the congregation with whom one might consider sharing a meal.

There is no reason to insist that the word “anyone” should be applied arbitrarily to “everyone,” irrespective of age or circumstances. Even Watchtower publications acknowledge that there should be some exceptions where family members are concerned. For example, a disfellowshipped husband is not to be shunned by his wife or children, and parents are not banned from speaking to their disfellowshipped children if they are not yet old enough to leave home.

But why should it end there?

Many share my opinion that there is scope to extend even more mercy in applying this scripture than is currently encouraged by the teachings of the Governing Body. Jesus said the following to the unrighteous pharisees:

Screen Shot 2016-06-29 at 13.38.56

Jesus identified mercy as playing a crucial role in the extent to which laws and principles should be enforced. Many do not think it is merciful that older teenagers, many of whom were baptized at an extremely young age (sometimes as young as 9), are forced out of their homes by their parents and then cruelly shunned, often for the rest of their lives, through a mistaken and abhorrent interpretation of the Apostle Paul’s advice.

The Society’s publications themselves warn that “no one should be forced to… choose between his beliefs and his family.” (July 2009 Awake!, p.9) However, they apply this reasoning to every religion but their own.

The scriptures clearly prescribe “shunning” purely as a measure for maintaining the spiritual cleanliness of the congregation, and not for the purpose of breaking up families. To go one step further and insist that shunning should also apply to families is both destructive and deeply unmerciful. It also violates the principle expressed by the Apostle Paul at 1 Timothy 5:8 where he said:

Screen Shot 2016-06-29 at 13.40.59

These and other teachings of the Governing Body are increasingly becoming a cause of sincere distress for many Witnesses who wish that the organization could adopt a more merciful and loving stance. In particular, one can now be disfellowshipped as an “apostate” merely for disagreeing with the Governing Body over this or other issues.

Only human

It is my sincere desire that by means of this website, and its annual surveys, the Governing Body will humbly consider the pleas of both myself and like-minded ones around the world who long for the Watch Tower Society to be a more loving organization – one that truly reflects the need for respect and tolerance toward other people’s beliefs.

The members of the Governing Body are only human, and no matter how much they may pray for wisdom and insight, they cannot possibly be fully aware of how their teachings and directives are impacting the lives of their fellow worshippers on a daily basis. That is what makes this survey website so important. It serves as a constant reminder for them to show greater kindness and mercy in undertaking the role that they have assumed as the faithful and discreet slave.

I would like to thank you in advance for your support for this site, and for getting involved in our important work.

Warmest regards,

new-cedars-signature3

61,158 thoughts on “About JW Watch (formerly JW Survey)

  • April 22, 2023 at 2:04 am
    Permalink

    Wonderful article! This is the type of info that are meant to
    be shared across the internet. Disgrace on Google for not positioning this put up upper!
    Come on over and talk over with my web site . Thank you =)

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 2:04 am
    Permalink

    Nice blog right here! Also your site lots up very fast!
    What host are you the use of? Can I get your associate link
    to your host? I want my web site loaded up as quickly
    as yours lol

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 2:14 am
    Permalink

    I am regular reader, how are you everybody? This paragraph posted at this web
    page is really nice.

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 2:33 am
    Permalink

    I pay a visit everyday some blogs and blogs to read content,
    except this website provides feature based articles.

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 6:39 am
    Permalink

    Howdy! This article couldn’t bbe written much better!
    Looking aat this article reminds me off my previous roommate!
    He consstantly kept talking aabout this. I’ll send thiss post to him.
    Fairly certain hhe will have a very good read. I appreciate you for sharing!

    Visit myy website; http://somersetsunset.net/

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 6:55 am
    Permalink

    We stumbled over here by a different web address and
    thought I might as well check things out. I like what I
    see so now i’m following you. Look forward to exploring your
    web page for a second time.

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 7:16 am
    Permalink

    Painters Lane Cove Nsw
    Quick One Professionals is a fully licensed and insured
    painting company that operates in Sydney. Since our inception in 2017 we have built a reputation of
    excellence and quality with our customers by listening to their needs
    and concerns. Our team comprises a number of professional, experienced, energetic and cautious painters who
    enjoy what they do and this is reflected
    in the results. We use only premium products and offer colour consultancy if desired to ensure excellent results.
    Does your house need a freshen up with a new coat
    of roof paint? The team at Empire Roofing can provide and complete a top quality roof painting service throughout Lane
    Cove West.
    No complaints are our goal, but if something is not right, we will fix it.
    With over 30 years of combined experience, ourpaintersoffer quality workmanship to their commercial
    and residential clients inLane Cove. We have been in the painting industry
    for over 15 years, which shows we can give your home or commercial property the tender
    love and care it deserves. Besides providing quality painting
    services, our team can also offer colour consulting to help you find the
    most suitable colour. Metropolitan Painters are a team of experienced,
    highly trained, Professional painters providing quality painting jobs at
    affordable prices.
    This would also apply if you are doing a particle renovation, and need to paint new
    rooms or spaces fast and evenly. If your home is looking a little tired
    on the outside you might want to give it a freshen up.
    Most homes need a fresh coat on exterior surfaces every five
    or 10 years, or more often if you are near the coast. Very happy with the kitchen cabinets and the front door
    painting.
    Once the final coat of paint is applied, the project is complete.
    That’s why it is critical that the preparation is thorough, because if not,
    it will show in the end result. When looking for the best
    roof painting Lane Cove has to offer, you need to look for experience and professionalism.
    With years of first-hand experience, excellent training coupled with passionate and professional
    staff, it’s clear to see why RoofingCorp is the best option for you.
    Whether you’re preparing your home for sale, or would simply like to give it a
    facelift, the team at RoofingCorp have what you need. A roof painting
    Lane Cove service from our experts will do the job while reinforcing the necessary protection.
    You can be assured that our quote will be affordable and competitive because our local identity means that you won’t be paying us for travel costs.
    Like you, we also have high expectations, so we perform an initial inspection throughout the painting process and address everything with the final coat.
    We also carry out a final quality control inspection afterwards to complete and sign off the job.
    This meticulous process delivers excellent results you
    can depend on.
    Big enough to handle the most complex of properties, and small enough to give
    you that personal service that you deserve. They were professional, polite, on-time,
    and a high quality result. So, whether it’s one of Lane Cove’s luxury apartments, large
    family homes, or outstanding mansions, ASL Painting Lane
    Cove can renovate, update, or redesign your paintwork.

    In fact there is every chance that you may have seen some of our team members working in your immediate area
    or around the plaza on commercial projects. Our professional team are dedicated to helping local business owners and residents bring their painting ideas to life.
    We are master painters specialising in all areas of painting including home painting, apartment painting, office painting,
    industrial painting and heritage building painting.
    Our years of experience working in Lane Cove combined with our professional expertise consistently
    delivers quality results at very affordable prices.
    With over 10+ years in the industry, SK Group has gained a reputation for
    its comprehensive house painting services.
    We provide exceptional results that are proper and timely , guaranteed.
    Our professionals is also safeguarded with public liability
    insurance to deliver you with ultimate assurance.
    We execute a extensive prep work and painting procedure
    to make certain that everything is done to customer satisfaction. A DIY painting
    project is prone to low-quality finishes.

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 7:33 am
    Permalink

    Can I simply say what a comfort to discover a person that genuinely
    knows what they are talking about online. You actually understand how to bring a problem to light and make it
    important. A lot more people should read this and understand this side of your story.
    I was surprised you’re not more popular because you certainly have the gift.

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 8:07 am
    Permalink

    Hi, i think that i saw you visited my blog thus i came to “return the favor”.I am trying
    to find things to improve my web site!I suppose its ok to use some
    of your ideas!!

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 8:19 am
    Permalink

    Six of the leading ten roles with the lowest female
    representation have been tech jobs, LinkedIn mentioned.

    Feel free to surf to my page; 여자알바

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 8:21 am
    Permalink

    Nice blog right here! Additionally your web site loads up very fast!

    What web host are you the use of? Can I am getting your associate link on your host?
    I want my web site loaded up as fast as yours lol

    My page – indospa

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 8:57 am
    Permalink

    Oh my goodness! Awesome article dude! Many thanks, However I am going through difficulties with your RSS.

    I don’t know why I can’t join it. Is there anyone else getting identical RSS issues?
    Anyone that knows the solution can you kindly respond?
    Thanx!!

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 9:16 am
    Permalink

    First of all I want to say fantastic blog!
    I had a quick question that I’d like to ask if you do not mind.

    I was curious to find out how you center yourself and clear your head before writing.
    I have had difficulty clearing my thoughts in getting my thoughts
    out. I do enjoy writing but it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes are wasted
    simply just trying to figure out how to begin. Any recommendations or tips?

    Appreciate it!

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 9:17 am
    Permalink

    Exceptional post however , I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this subject?
    I’d be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit
    more. Appreciate it!

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 10:15 am
    Permalink

    If you want to grow your knowledge just keep visiting this web site and be updated with the most recent information posted here.

    Reply
  • April 22, 2023 at 10:20 am
    Permalink

    همه چیز درباره فیلم برادران لیلا
    تنها فرزند خانواده که به ندرت توسط چیزی یا کسی فریب می‌خورد، لیلا است.
    لیلا مصلحت‌گرا و مجرد است و تنها فرزند خانواده محسوب
    می‌شود که شغل و درآمدی مناسبی دارد.
    او مدام شاهد تصمیمات اشتباه پدر و برادرانش است و همینیکی از نکات مهم در
    این فیلم به شمار می‌رود که
    پر از ایده‌ها و نقدهای اجتماعی است.
    فیلم برادران لیلا با اینکه فیلمی کامل به حساب نمی‌آید اما فیلمساز توانسته
    هدف خود را به خوبی به نمایش بگذارد.

    همچنین او سعی دارد از طریق سختی‌های بی‌شمار یک خانواده، وضعیت ایران را نشان دهد.

    او در فیلم‌سازان برجسته‌ای چون
    رسول صدرعاملی، واروژ و اصغر
    فرهادی بازی کرده و جوایز از جمله جایزه بهترین زن از
    جشنواره فیلم لوکارنو سوئیس سوئیس و سیمرغ بلورین بهترین بازیگر نقش اول زن زن
    جشنواره فجر را دریافت کرده است. فیلم برادران لیلی انصافا فیلم بزرگ و مهمی است، هر چند کامل نیست و دوربین رودست
    مانند دوربین رودست کارهای
    اصغر فرهادی، تاثیر خودش را نمی گذارد.
    ترانه علیدوستی بازیگر کوچکی نیست اما
    همچنان همان است که فرهادی گفته بود!
    (از حفظ بازی نکن، بگذار واکنش
    تو در لحظه شکل بگیرد) و البته علیدوستی در چند
    سکانس کاملا از حفظ بازی می کند.
    اگر داستان علی الظاهر کمی ابکی به نظر می‌رسد، روستایی اجازه نمی‌دهد هنگام
    تماشای فیلم همچین حسی به مخاطب دست دهد.
    سعید روستایی صحنه‌ها را با انرژی فیلم‌های مستند شلوغ
    به تصویر می‌کشد و ماهرانه از کلیشه‌های ملودراماتیک دوری می‌کند.

    او می‌داند در چه زمانی مقیاسی بزرگ را به نمایش در بیاورد و در فیلم «برادران لیلا» در صحنه‌ی کارخانه یا صحنه‌ی عروسی این کار را انجام داده بود که یادآور فیلم‌سازهایی همچون مایکل چیمینو و فرانسیس فورد کاپولا است.
    نقد فیلم برادران لیلاحتی اگر
    تمرکز فیلم بر روی مردان خانواده باشد، فیلمِ
    برادران لیلا در کل فیلمی با محوریتِ کاراکترِ لیلا
    با بازی خوبِ ترانه علیدوستی است.
    این بازیگر تجسم زنی است که با سنت‌های
    مندرس خانوادگی مبارزه می‌کند و تسلیم نمی‌شود.
    این فیلم با وجود دیالوگ‌های زیاد و طولانی بودن بیش از
    حد، یک تراژدی نسبتا موفق است.

    منوچهر (با بازی پیمان معادی) که تن به کار نمی‌دهد به دنبال‌ طرح‌های حیله‌گرانه برای تصاحب ثروت‌های بادآورده است و علیرضا (با بازی نوید محمدزاده) به تازگی کار در کارخانه را رها
    کرده چرا که روسا با دستمزد درخواستی‌اش موافقت نکرده‌اند.
    نقد فیلم برادران لیلاسعید روستایی
    فیلم‌ساز ایرانی یک درام
    خانوادگی بزرگ، جذاب و شخصیت‌محور را به سبک ایتالیایی-آمریکایی با اجراهای خشن،
    صحنه بزرگ عروسی و تاثیرپذیری‌هایی از «روکو و برادرانش» ساخته ویسکونتی و «پدرخوانده»ی
    کوپولا ارائه می‌کند. حتی در نزاع‌ها
    و مناقشه‌های فیلم نشانه‌هایی
    از آرتور میلر هم یافت می‌شود.
    نقد فیلم برادران لیلالیلا در ۴۰ سالگی تمام زندگی خود را
    صرف مراقبت از پدر و مادر و چهار برادرش کرده است.
    در کشوری که درگیر تحریم‌های اقتصادی بین‌المللی است، خانواده دائماً با هم بحث
    می‌کنند و زیر بار بدهی‌ خُرد می‌شوند.لیلا در
    حالی که برادرانش در تلاش برای گذراندن زندگی
    خود هستند، نقشه‌ای می‌کشد
    تا با راه اندازی یک تجارت
    خانوادگی آنها را از فقر نجات دهد.

    حتی چنان گفته شده از این دردها خودمونیم خسته
    شدیم و برامون هم دیگه شنیدنش و تکرارشون بدتر عصبیمون
    میکنه . نقشه فرهاد تنها یکی از برنامه‌های
    این خواهر و برادران است که برای پول درآوردن به اجرا می‌گذارند و یکدیگر را گول می‌زنند تا بتوانند
    دیگری را از نابودی نجات بدهند. در فیلم، تنش‌ها به صورت منظم و مداوم در موقعیت‌های مختلف و با حضور کاراکترهای متفاوت احساس می‎‌شود و صحنه‌های درام خون‌گرمی را ایجاد می‌کند که در
    آن بازیگران به سبکی پرخاشگرانه نقش‌آفرینی
    می‌کنند که یادآور سبک جان کاساوتیس است.
    دیوید جنکینز با اشاره به فیلم‌نامه درخشان برادران لیلا، توانایی سعید روستایی در نگارش چنین متنی را ستایش می‌کند؛
    خلاصه‌ای پرجنب و جوش از
    مکالمات احساسی و بحث‌های متناقض که به کمال عاطفی و روایی می‌رسد.

    به ویژه هنگامی که موضوع درام اجتماعی درک زمان حال
    است؛ و تاریخ و آن تصویری که از جهان نشان می‌دهد، نقشی تعیین‌کننده دارد.

    این تصویر، چنان‌که لوکاچ تبیین نموده است، به
    مثابه آینه‌ای انسان را به شناخت
    و به تکامل می‌رساند. حال آن‌که نمایش ناتورالیستی و بی‌رحمانۀ واقعیت، از ارائۀ تصویر چنین
    انسانی عاجز بوده و محدود به بیان دیدگاه‌های
    شخصی هنرمند است؛ که بیش از هر چیز،
    سیاسی و ایدئولوژیک است. به بیان روشن‌تر روستایی با وام‌گرفتن واقعیت و تقلیل دادن ان به مادۀ خام، جهانی را بر
    مبنای برداشتی که در نظر دارد، شکل داده
    و بازنمایی می‌کند؛ اما موفق نمی‌شود فردیتِ شخصیت‌های فیلمش را با روح
    زمانه‌اشان پیوند زند.
    حتی در دعواها و درگیری های فیلم هم نشانه هایی از آرتور میلر دیده می شود.
    پدر آن‌ها نیز اسماعیل با بازی
    سعید پورصمیمی است که می‌خواهد بچه‌هایش و
    همچنین خانواده و طایفه‌اش به او احترام بگذارند، به خصوص پس از اینکه پدرسالار پیر این
    خاندان از دنیا می‌رود و همین باعث می‌شود تا اسماعیل
    خودش را فرد مناسبی برای جایگاه او ببیند.
    اما از این لایه اتفاقا فراگیر و به اصطلاح تماشاگر پسند که بگذریم، فیلم در
    سطح دیگری می‌کوشد با استفاده از همان پوسته‌ی روبنایی‌اش روند فروپاشی خانواده درون فیلم را واکاوی
    کند که گاها به دلایل گوناگون به تمثیل و تشبیه روی می‌آورد.

    از اولین بازی‌های دیده شده نوید محمد زاده
    که تا پای برنده سیمرغ بهترین بازیگر مرد جشنواره
    فجر او را برد، فیلم من عصبانی نیستم بود.

    او تاکنون جوایز بسیاری برنده شده و تیپ‌های شخصیتی زیادی بازی کرده است.
    در مقایسه فیلمی مثل برادران لیلا می‌تواند بسیار شوکه کننده باشد و
    فشار جامعه ایران را به بیننده القا
    کند، بدون فراهم کردن زمینه مورد نیاز.

    او مصلحت‌گرا و مجرد است و تنها فرزند خانواده محسوب می‌شود که شغلی مناسبی دارد.
    از آنجا که او یک زن است، معمولا توسط پدر و برادران خود نادیده گرفته می‌شود.

    او شاهد است که پدر و برادرانش پشت سر هم تصمیمات اشتباهی اتخاذ می‌کنند و همین، یکی
    از نکات مهم در فیلم به شمار می‌رود
    که پر از ایده‌ها و نقدهای اجتماعی است.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *